Tuesday, June 28, 2005

The Nameless Monster

The Nameless Monster

Once upon a time, there lived a nameless monster.
The monster was dying to have a name so badly.
So the monster decided to set out on a journey to find itself a name.
But the world was such a large place.
So the monster split into two and went on two separate journeys.
One went to the East and the other went to the West.
The monster that went to the east found a village.

There was a blacksmith at the village entrance.
"Mr.Blacksmith, please give me your name" said the monster.
"I can't give you my name" replied the blacksmith.
"If you give me your name I will jump inside you and make you stronger in return." said the monster.
"Really? I'll give you my name if you can make me stronger.", the blacksmith told the monster.
The monster jumped inside the blacksmith.
The monster became Otto the blacksmith.
Otto the blacksmith was the strongest man in the village.
But one day he said:
"Look at me! Look at me!"
"The monster inside of me has grown this big!"
*Chomp, chomp, munch, munch, gobble, gobble, gulp*
The hungry monster ate Otto from the inside out.

The monster then went back to become a monster without a name.
Even though he jumped inside Hans the shoemaker....
*Chomp, chomp, munch, munch, gobble, gobble, gulp*
He went back to being a monster without a name again.
Even though he jumped inside Thomas the hunter.....
*Chomp, chomp, munch, munch, gobble, gobble, gulp*
He still went back to being a monster without a name.
The monster then went to a castle to find a wonderful name.
Inside the castle, there was a very sick boy.
"I'll make you stronger if you give me your name" said the monster
In reply, the boy told him "I'll give you my name if you can cure my illness and make me stronger."
So the monster jumped inside the boy.
The boy became very healthy.

The King was delighted.
"The prince is well! The prince is well!" said the King.
The monster became fond of the boy's name.
He also grew fond of his life inside the castle.
That's why he endured even when he became hungry.
Every day, even when his stomach became very empty, he endured.
But then he became so hungry....
"Look at me! Look at me!" said the boy.
"The monster inside of me has grown this big!"
The boy then ate his father, servants, and everyone.
*Chomp, chomp, munch, munch, gobble, gobble, gulp*
Because everyone was gone....
The boy left on a journey
He walked and walked for days.....

One day the boy met the monster that went west
"I have a name" said the boy.
"It's a wonderful name."
And then the monster that went west said...
"I don't need a name."
"I'm happy even if I don't have a name."
"Because we're monsters without names."
The boy ate the monster that went west.
Even though he now had a name....
There was no one left to call him by his name.
Johan.
It is a wonderful name.

Decided to put this story up here...meant for future discussion. Another reason is that I'm really attracted to this story...It seems to be so simple and yet so profound.

8 comments:

Unknown said...

Ummm hi there!
Chomp, chomp, munch, munch, gobble, gobble, gulp...that's kinda catchy!! lol

It's a good story even thugh I don't understand why in the world did the monster want a name!?? He should have remained nameless and accept himself as he was.

Anonymous said...

It might be an identity-crisis. Since name is associated with identity, the monster desperately wanted just that. To be an individual, one needs to feel unique. But since a monster is not human (unique in other words), it tries to take over other's identities to hopefully make it its own.

Quite alike humans, who desperately want a "grand name", even if it means taking over someone else's... :3

Anonymous said...

For the two of you above, this story is a fairy tale in the manga "Monster".

Inside the story, this fairy tale is said to be a czech story, but I don't think the fairy tale really exists in real world.

Anyway, this story is used in the manga in order to resolve some of the mystery in the story. And Johan, the "name" of the nameless monster, is actually one of the character in the manga. So the author is using this story to develop this main plot of the manga

Therefore, this story doesn't seem to make any sense because it is just a tool for the plot in "monster" to develop. So many people who read this story but have not read "monster" before would not know the meaning of it.

By the way, monster is a great mange and it consists a lot of suspense. So if you are trying to find a manga to read, monster would be a great choice.

Anonymous said...

"“And I stood upon the sand of the sea, and saw a beast rise up out of the sea,
having seven heads and ten horns, and upon his horns ten crowns,
and upon his heads the name of blasphemy.
And they worshipped the dragon which gave power unto the beast
and they worshipped the beast, saying
"Who is like unto the beast?
Who is able to make war with him?"”
(The Revelation of Saint John the Divine, 13:1-4)"

2:nd poster:

I'm quite aware of the manga and the anime. You might have been under the impression that I came by this post by 'accident' - but I specifically searched through Google for "The nameless monster".

And I analyzed it separately from the anime/manga (to a certain degree) to gain some insight later on a re-watch. :3

Anonymous said...

A large amount om manga-authors' usually get in quite deep in their characters' at creation/development. So they fabricate a story befitting that character, in this case, 'the nameless monster' symbolizes Johan and his psyche/train of thought.

Therefore, a separate analysis is much appreciated.

Unknown said...

Uhm, pardon the intrusion, but isn't it an actual Czech book that they based the anime around? Or was it that they made the book from the anime... either way, it exists, and you can get it in english. Personally, I'd prefer the Czech copy :)... not that I... can read Czech...

riri wibianto said...

Hi there,

Me too actually try to separately analyze this story from the anime/manga. It's end up like I find myself categorized it as a kind of metafiction and try to analyze the actual message it tries to tell to the reader who read it as a separated story also... Hmm, one friend told me this story could be meaningless if we try to analyze it separately from the manga. But hey, the characters (like Johan, Nina, and Grimmer) are read it as an individual story, aren't they? I mean, if you remember that Franz Bonaparta actually want to tell them that 'human could be anything...

Well, I really looking for chance to discuss this with you. I'll leave my email, please send me and let me know if you didn't mind to have some conversation with me :)

Peace

madameriri@gmail.com

Anonymous said...

Esta historia como bien dicen es del manga de NAOKI URASAWA, PERO NO CONCUERDO CON LA PERSONA QUE DICE QUE NO TIENE SIGNIFICADO Y solo existe para encajar en la historia , estoy deacuerdo con los primeros en que el significado es sumamente profundo